From the category archives:

Paternalism

Outing Myself (from the Cannabis Closet)

April 3, 2009

In my latest column for The Week, I argue that the drug war is stupid, deadly, and unjust and try to do my small part to normalize marijuana use. My favorite reaction so far comes from Jossip:
Holy shit Wilkinson, you’re really putting yourself on the line buddy! A upper-class, white Libertarian admits to smoking pot. [...]

Read the full article →

Let Them Have Their Weed!

February 27, 2009

This is excellent news: “Holder Vows To End Raids On Medical Marijuana Clubs.”

Read the full article →

More Thoughts on “Choice Architecture” and “Libertarian Paternalism”

October 1, 2008

In the comments below, Berger writes of my Nudge review:
this seems pretty caustic…especially when you seem to grant their central premise: there is no such thing as neutral choice architecture.
But who contests it? Constitutional design, law and economics, policy analysis, etc. all rest solidly on the idea that choices are responsive to features of the [...]

Read the full article →

“Irrational” Choice and the Persistence of Lives Well-Lived

May 26, 2008

Say you think the falsehood of the homo economicus model provides some kind of special basis for a new kind of paternalism. Does that mean you think people up to now have been making a hash out of their lives? Maybe you do, which is why you think people continue to smoke or get really, [...]

Read the full article →

John Cassidy on Libertarian Paternalism: Way Too Libertarian!

May 23, 2008

John Cassidy’s philosophically half-baked exploration of neuroeconomics a couple years back in the New Yorker inspired me to write an essay-length reply. I suspected then that he really liked what he erroneously saw as the paternalistic upshot of behavioral and neuro- economics, and was deliberately reading the results in a way that would seem to [...]

Read the full article →

Nudge Forum

May 13, 2008

If you’re interested, you can watch or listen to the Cato Forum on Cass Sunstein and Richard Thaler’s Nudge here. My comments are last, after Sunstein and Chorvat’s.

Read the full article →

Nussbaum on Sex Work

April 26, 2008

In all the dust of last month’s prostitution debate, I somehow missed philosopher Martha Nussbaum’s excellent op-ed, in which she espouses a view almost identical to the Howley-Wilkinson line.
Why are there laws against prostitution? All of us, with the exception of the independently wealthy and the unemployed, take money for the use of our body. [...]

Read the full article →

Choice Architecture and Paternalism

April 20, 2008

I’m trying to get clear on what Sunstein and Thaler mean, and it’s not easy, since they basically make up their own private language, and then act puzzled by the idea that some people might be a little confused by what they have in mind.
So a “choice architect” is basically anyone that organizes “the context [...]

Read the full article →

Nudge

April 20, 2008

The New York Times reports that a bunch of ex-military on-air “analysts” are in bed with both military contractors and the Bush administration:
Records and interviews show how the Bush administration has used its control over access and information in an effort to transform the analysts into a kind of media Trojan horse — an instrument [...]

Read the full article →

The Place of Post-Constitutional Choice Architecture

April 3, 2008

In comments below, Berger asks this question in response to my concession of the non-neutrality of choice architecture, (which was in fact what I had in mind when posing the cryptic “dissertation topic” question about liberal neutrality at the bottom of the post):
It seems to me that if you concede that there is no such [...]

Read the full article →

How to Be Grotesquely Reductionist and Utilitarian about Human Love and Life

March 17, 2008

This post by one “Deep Thought” is a brilliant example:
This isn’t rocket science; men with easy access to prostitution or to promiscuous women have little incentive to marry. Suddenly there is nothing to offset their legal and financial obligations as a husband – so why take on the obligation? Women who are promiscuous face disease, [...]

Read the full article →

How Sex Is (and Isn’t) Different, Part II

March 17, 2008

Everything is what it is. Sex work is different from carpentry and it is different from surgery. It is like carpentry and surgery in that it is a way of renting one’s body. It is like surgery in requiring some hardening and compartmentalization. It is not like surgery in that it involves a different set [...]

Read the full article →

How Sex Is Different, Part I

March 16, 2008

I’ve got time to kill while waiting in LAX, so I might as well try to clarify my position on prostitution by saying how I think sex is different from other kinds of human activity. Obviously, sex is central to reproduction, and reproduction is central to natural selection, and natural selection is central to why [...]

Read the full article →

Selling Sex Is OK and Child Abuse Isn’t

March 15, 2008

I wanted to reply to Ross’s post on the so-called Wilkinson-Howley worldview, but I had to go to L.A. for a little political theory conference at UCLA, where I am now. Let’s see if I can clarify a few things. Ross writes:
Given the premises of the pro-prostitution worldview, what’s so abusive and damaging about incest [...]

Read the full article →

Justifying the Prohibition of Markets in Sexual Services

March 13, 2008

I liked Ross Douthat’s first post on prostitution. He identifies the real question at issue, which is the truth or falsity of this claim:
[R]enting out your body to satisfy another person’s sexual needs is a form of self-inflicted violence serious enough to merit legal sanction …
The whole case for banning trade in sexual services stands [...]

Read the full article →