home

Questionable Tautologies?

From the incomparable, self-satirizing Stirling Newberry:

Even today there are people arguing that Ayn Rand is a major “liberal” theorist, and fighting to preserve her holy memory on the internet. This from a philosophy that starts out from two questionable tautologies and worships getting cancer. No rhapsody anywhere in Rand’s books surpasses her paean to smoking.

I don’t know, if I’m going to question anything, it’s not going to be a logical truth! And of course, the worst thing about Rand is… what? Smoking! This guy is a master of the unedited non-sequitur brain dump. Does he give money to Josh Marshall or something?
[HT: Diana Hsieh.]

5 Responses to “Questionable Tautologies?”

  1. Roger Sweeny
    August 23rd, 2006 11:31
    1

    Megan McArdle enlists Mark Twain to mock Newberry (partly in response to this post):

    http://www.janegalt.net/blog/archives/005865.html

  2. Brian Moore
    August 23rd, 2006 15:41
    2

    Is it my fault or his if I have absolutely no idea what he is trying to say?

  3. asg
    August 24th, 2006 06:51
    3

    I can’t believe he’s for real. In a few months he’ll tell everyone that the game’s up.

  4. Tim Worstall
    August 24th, 2006 07:09
    4

    Oh, C’mon, Newberry is a satirist. Has to be. Maybe not a very good one, but really, no one can actually be making those statements seriously.

    Can they?

  5. gqlnztqidcg
    October 3rd, 2006 17:53
    5

    sdopvgtpnu…

    kpqnpfame djwvqkfkily hdpurmero pdxowfxw …

Leave a Reply

Recent Comments

Reading